Budget FAIL. And a debt update.

by jolyn on June 15, 2010

in Dave Ramsey,Debt,On Budgeting

Hmm… Mid-June and I’m finally ready to talk about May? Yea. It’s been a few of those weeks.

Debt Update

Not very exciting. We’re in minimum mode right now. As in, just making minimum payments. Our debt snowball is just sitting there, in limbo. Waiting for a couple of major life changes (aka Selling a house and Moving cross-country) that may or may not completely eradicate two huge debts.

But our consumer debt is still gone! (Have I mentioned that lately? ;) )

But we still have lots of mortgage debt!

As of May 2010:

  1. First Mortgage:  $170,440.66
  2. Second Mortgage:  $31,427.28
  3. Rental Property:  $108,585.56

Total Debt:  $310,453.50

This is a difference of $560.56 from the $311,014.06 owed in primary and rental mortgage debt at the end of April.

Payments Breakdown:

  1. First Mortgage: $1538.63
  2. Second Mortgage: $283.90
  3. Rental Property: $758.00

Total Monthly Payments: $2580.53

Are you paying attention? Over $2000 of these payments is going toward interest. Yuck.

Have you ever run the numbers on your regular monthly payments to figure out how much actually goes toward paying off the debt and not just toward the interest to thank that nice bank for loaning you the money? It’s a good exercise. But you might want to sit down first.

What Would Dave Ramsey Do?

If we did not have a house to sell and weren’t moving before the year was out, we would be tackling our second mortgage. According to Dave Ramsey…

“Generally speaking, if your second mortgage is more than 50 percent of your gross annual income, you should not put it in the Debt Snowball.”

(The Total Money Makeover p. 130)

Our second mortgage is less than 50 percent of our gross annual income, which would normally put it in step two of The Seven Baby Steps, if you’re following Dave Ramsey’s Journey to Financial Peace.

These are not Normal Times

Clearly, we need to focus on bulking up our savings right now rather than paying off more debt in the event that we need to bring some cash to the closing table. And we are — but not nearly with the zeal that we were paying off our debt.

I don’t know if it’s the change of John coming home from his deployment, the frenetic stress of finding out we’re moving a year earlier than originally scheduled, or just the laziness of resting on our laurels of paying off the almost $20,000 we had in consumer debt in less than a year. But our budgeting is shot all to Hades. Poof! It’s gone. We’ve been spending money left and right like it’s going out of style. And it’s mostly on food (though not all).

During our debt snowball last year, I took great pride and relief in how much we saved (and therefore debt eliminated) by not eating out. Like, at all. We went at least six months without so much as ordering out a pizza.

Enter May

I knew I was going to let up on the eating out once our initial snowball was done. And when I found out we were moving and I had to scramble to get this house up for sale, I told myself I was really going to relax and let us enjoy some time eating out and getting ice cream and whatnot and not worry so much about our budget for once.

And then Pandora’s Box blew wide open.

I don’t at all begrudge the graduation gifts that came with May (I am the aunt of two high school graduates. *gulp*) or the new toys that I got my younger son or the music CD(s) that I bought my daughter or the summer class I signed my teenager up for to get him a head start on some high school credit. And I’m certainly not regretting our new mattress. It’s the mindless-ness of all the other little things. All the other stuff that came up that found me saying, “Sure, why not.” No budget, no planning. It’s telling that I can’t even readily give a number to it all.

And the eating out? I wish I could say that we just enjoyed ourselves for a time then reined ourselves in. We did spend $183.35 on takeout or eating out for the month of May, after all.

But I just ran some numbers for June. Which is only half over. And so far we have spent $192.61 just on eating out. Yes, John is home and we’ve been doing things as a family. But almost $200? I’m just not sure how I feel about that. Food is a huge budget buster for families. (For everyone?) After doing so well on it for so long (I’m strictly referring to the cost of eating out here) I hate to see it take over our budget and keep us from meeting our other financial goals as soon as we could otherwise.

I can definitely see how difficult it is to break a habit of eating out regularly. Just in these few weeks of doing it again with the kids, they have caught on and are asking for it more and more. And it starts feeling so easy. Oy, vey.

Finances as a Couple

Overall, John and I are doing a much better job of discussing and planning for bigger-ticket items: It’s the little things that seem to be out of control. And I’m afraid I am to blame. (Can you say Thrift Store?)

It’s clear that I need to re-motivate myself. And that John and I are overdue for a proper sit-down: Although we’re preparing better for bigger purchases (such as new tires for the car this month — $609.62. Ooch.) we have yet to sit down side-by-side and number crunch and geeky-talk financial priorities since he’s been home.

It’s also clear that John has not been consumed by the numbers as I have. I suppose you could say he’s had other things on his mind, like his recent deployment and his upcoming school and his upcoming promotion (yea!) and this study program he’s supposed to be completing because of the promotion and everything else that goes along with the pesky business of earning a living. But just today (or yesterday?) he called me from work where he was filling out a survey form, and he asked me for the amount we owed in consumer debt. “Consumer debt? You mean that stuff we just paid off?”

So tell me, how could he have missed that? I think we’ve got some work to do. Oy, vey.

Did you like this? Share it with your friends!
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Add to favorites
  • email
  • MySpace
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter
Widget Created Thanks to Frugal Zeitgeist and Beating Broke

{ 1 trackback }

Tweets that mention Budget FAIL. And a debt update. -- Topsy.com
June 16, 2010 at 6:54 am

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

Rachel June 17, 2010 at 10:59 am

You’re doing such a great job! I know how hard it can be to loose sight of a budget when you’re eating out a lot. It can be addicting, and before you know it, poof, there went the money! But you deserve a break- it’s good to celebrate the little milestones to give you momemtum to keep on going. As long as no new debt is accumulated that is!

[Reply]

myfinancialobjectives June 16, 2010 at 8:15 pm

I bet that was an awesome feeling to be able to say “you mean that debt we just paid off”. Ahh what a wonderful feeling!

Spending time with your family and enjoying each others company is well worth the money. Think about this, when your kids are off at college, or after college, you will probably hardly see them. Looking back, you man not regret those times when you went out to eat so much:)

Budgeting is awesome, and I commend you on how well you have been keeping track of it, but your family and the memories you create during these years are so much more important:)

[Reply]

jolyn Reply:

Actually, what I felt at the time was annoyance! I mean, wasn’t he there? ;)

I totally agree about spending time with family. Part of my desire to live debt- and credit-free and eschew the clutter of “stuff” in our lives is to have the time and money to devote to experiences as a family. There’s a balance, though: money is not required to enjoy time as a family. Eating out occasionally is awesome. But that shouldn’t be our fall-back to spending time as a family! Not that it is, but the point of running the numbers is to evaluate things like that.
Thus ends my rant. :)

[Reply]

Nikki June 16, 2010 at 1:21 pm

Shoot, I could relate to several aspects of your post. I work in a public school system and am on summer vacation, and I went out to lunch with 3 friends last week. Normally I don’t eat out at all. I can’t be doing that all summer. lol And I have more free time to shop now as well, so even if I only pick up 1-2 little things, all the receipts add up. And I’ve totally blown our grocery budget this month…like by over $200. Glad to read it isn’t just me. Maybe summertime puts us in a different financial frame of mind. And of course when I’m working I don’t have time to eat out or shop. I do want the focus-on-budget frame of mind back. Guess I need to go hang out with my Dave Ramsey friends.

[Reply]

Jerilyn June 16, 2010 at 10:32 am

You’ve done a great job! Breaks are necessary and good as long as you don’t go backward (accumulate debt). You’re going to be fine.
It would be so easy to eat out a lot. You just get so tired of planning, shopping, and then cooking (and cleaning up). I know quite a few people who eat out every day, often twice a day. But not us, even with no kids to feed. Just can’t justify the expense. But it sure is a nice treat.
I just read an article by Suze Orman about people with high credit scores not having enough debt history to qualify for a loan. I think her advice was – use a credit card occasionally but pay it off at the end of the month.

[Reply]

kelly June 16, 2010 at 8:06 am

Congratulations on doing such a great job with your debt snowball! You have kept me motivated to say “NO” to my children in order to stay on budget. I think it’s just fine to take a breather and splurge on a meal or two out. As the mom it’s also nice to be the “YES” man, hero for the moment. Take your breather and then you can get back in intense on winning.

[Reply]

jolyn Reply:

Thanks, Kelly. It’s just so fun to be the “yes” mom, isn’t it? I heard a quote the other day, “I’m not broke, I’m on a budget!” I think it’s one I’m going to start using soon. It is valuable for kids to learn that, just because you have money, doesn’t mean you should spend it on [fill in the blank]. I think I need to be telling myself that again, too…

[Reply]

Kristin @ Peace, Love and Muesli June 16, 2010 at 8:04 am

I go WAY over budget on food. And we don’t eat out very much. And my girls hardly eat. I blame the blog!
Ken and I are overdo for a financial sit down too. Can we make a pack to get this done before Monday?

[Reply]

jolyn Reply:

Oh, my. Before Monday? That should be very doable! Yet, my how the days fly… Yes! Let’s do it! It’s a pact!

[Reply]

Mysti June 16, 2010 at 7:57 am

Food is our worst budget buster. I have commented on my own blog about this over and over. I honestly don’t think that all is lost for you though. You are still in celebration mode over having John home. Not that that is a good excuse to spend money like it is going out of style….but maybe that is a little reprieve from guilt.

And you need to celebrate that you are still consumer debt free, while buying a new mattress, tires, kid stuff, etc!!!!

You are doing GREAT….really!!!!!!

(Oh, and yes, I have done the exercise of figuring out how much of my payment goes to interest…..staggering!!)

[Reply]

jolyn Reply:

Thanks, Mysti. I knew I could count on you to keep me in line. We should only celebrate for so long. It’s amazing how quickly the kids “adapt”! Let’s hope it can go the other way… ;)

[Reply]

Susan June 16, 2010 at 7:02 am

It’s interesting as I read your posts from a US residence point of view as Expat’s are having a harder time getting Mortgage loans approved right now. Many of us, because we are on Corporate packages, are able to pay off our debts while overseas and if we sold our homes in the States, have not carried a mortgage for years. Thus Expats tend to be in a cash (home equity sits in the bank) heavy position but with relatively little debt/credit card use in the States – except for the red-flag large airline purchases for trips home.
We have several friends who have returned(ing) home and encounter problems in obtaining mortgage loans in the last year – solid jobs, 20% down in cash, great credit scores BUT not enough revolving consumer debt – no appliances, tv/electronics, cars, etc…. purchased for a number of years.
Interesting how the system works – penalizes you for not paying down your debt OR penalizes you for not having enough (they don’t like to see you pay it off every month truth be told – they aren’t earning any interest off you).
So – we are actually meeting with a banker on our home leave trip to find out “What can we do in this next year while overseas to prepare for buying a house next year on our return?”
The rules have changed. Interesting.

[Reply]

jolyn Reply:

Interesting, if their credit scores are great then why are the banks looking at their lack of revolving credit? Yes, the rules are changing, and mostly for the better. What’s not good is that common sense still seems to be in short supply. If I were in your friends’ shoes I’d look into working with a smaller bank where they might know someone, or someone who knows someone, who can vouch for them. We actually have that with a small bank in my hometown where we have done business in the past when we didn’t have much credit to speak of. Luckily we have not had any trouble in recent years and have mainly stuck with doing business through our main financial institution, USAA.
Speaking of them — do any have ties to USAA? It’s a great financial institution to do business with for people who move a lot or who travel. People think it’s only for military, but it’s not. You might want to check into it.

[Reply]

Financial Samurai June 16, 2010 at 12:11 am

Keep up the good work in highlighting your debt and making it real to you!

Although you might be spending more than you want, are you having fun doing it? If so, that counts for something!

Sam

[Reply]

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

Improve the web with Nofollow Reciprocity.